NICETOWN Blackout Curtains vs Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of NICETOWN Blackout Curtains and Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Updated 2026-03-09 Independently reviewed
NICETOWN Blackout Curtains

NICETOWN Blackout Curtains

9.1/10
$27 /one-time
VS
Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains

Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains

8.6/10
$55 /one-time

Feature Comparison

Feature NICETOWN Blackout Curtains Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains
Light Blocking 99% 90-95%
Material Polyester triple-weave Polyester blend
Thermal lining Yes Yes
Noise Reduction Moderate
Care Machine washable Machine washable
Hanging Grommet top Rod pocket
Sizes 42x63 to 52x96 inches Standard sizes
Colors 20+ options Curated palette
Style Designer aesthetic

NICETOWN Blackout Curtains

Pros

  • 99% light blocking in testing
  • Thermal lining for insulation
  • Noise reduction
  • Machine washable
  • Multiple colors and sizes
  • Grommet top for easy hanging
  • Affordable price

Cons

  • May need to size up for full coverage
  • Some colors show slight light bleed at edges

Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains

Pros

  • Designer aesthetic
  • Good light blocking
  • Quality construction
  • Thermal lining
  • Multiple colors and patterns
  • Linen-look options
  • Target/Walmart availability

Cons

  • Higher price point
  • Some styles less blackout than others

Our Verdict

NICETOWN Blackout Curtains

Best overall blackout curtains for apartments—excellent light blocking and value.

Special Deal Available — See Offer

Magnolia Home Blackout Curtains

Best for design-conscious renters who want blackout with style.

Price Drop Alert — View Deal Now

Our Methodology

We test each blackout curtain for light blocking percentage, thermal insulation, noise reduction, and durability. Details on testing process. No manufacturer has editorial influence.

Related Comparisons

Ranked List

Best Blackout Curtains 2026 – Tested & Ranked for Apartments

We tested 10+ blackout curtains for apartments. Here are our top picks for light blocking, insulation, and renter-friendly features.

Overview

Compare Blackout Curtains – Side-by-Side Specs

Compare light blocking, insulation, materials, and pricing across all top blackout curtains for apartments.

Compare

Compare BlackoutPick Products — Pick Two to Compare

Choose any two products to see a detailed side-by-side comparison. Compare specs, features, and value.

Head to Head

NICETOWN vs Deconovo Blackout Curtains – Which Wins for Apartments?

We compare the two top-rated blackout curtains: NICETOWN's triple-weave vs Deconovo's 3-pass lining. Which is better for apartments?

Head to Head

NICETOWN Blackout Curtains vs Eclipse Curtains Blackout Energy — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of NICETOWN Blackout Curtains and Eclipse Curtains Blackout Energy. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Head to Head

NICETOWN Blackout Curtains vs Amazon Essentials Blackout Curtain — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of NICETOWN Blackout Curtains and Amazon Essentials Blackout Curtain. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.

Head to Head

NICETOWN Blackout Curtains vs H.VERSAILTEX Blackout Curtains — Which Should You Buy?

Side-by-side comparison of NICETOWN Blackout Curtains and H.VERSAILTEX Blackout Curtains. We compare specs, performance, and value to help you decide.